Is It Worth Using a Separate Drive for Backups on Linux?

Unison

Well-known member
VIP

Is It Worth Using a Separate Drive for Backups on Linux?​


After recently sorting out my Linux storage, it got me thinking about backups and where we actually keep them.


It’s very easy to set up Timeshift or another backup program and assume everything is safe because it says the backup completed successfully. But if those backups are sitting on the same physical drive as the operating system, a failed SSD could potentially take both the system and the backups with it.


I now prefer having the operating system on one drive and backups/snapshots on a completely separate physical drive.


There are a few advantages:


  • If the main SSD fails, the backup drive should still be intact.
  • A clean Linux reinstall becomes much less worrying.
  • Older HDDs and SSDs can be put to good use instead of sitting in a drawer.
  • Timeshift snapshots don't consume space on the main system drive.
  • Important personal files can have another backup independently of the OS.

Of course, a second internal drive still isn't a complete backup strategy. Theft, electrical damage or accidentally deleting something could potentially affect both drives, so genuinely important files should ideally have another copy elsewhere too.


One thing I've learned is that a backup isn't really a backup if losing one piece of hardware loses both copies.


How do others here handle Linux backups?


Do you use another internal drive, USB storage, a NAS, cloud storage — or a mixture of them?
 
On my set up I cover both of your stated concerns all my daily timeshift and backups on my main 2 machines go to a second drive in comp, but being an old systems computer man back in the day, I have a clone of both machines on a external drives which I update after any major changes or every 3 months which ever comes first. Then these are kept in a safe place.
 
On my set up I cover both of your stated concerns all my daily timeshift and backups on my main 2 machines go to a second drive in comp, but being an old systems computer man back in the day, I have a clone of both machines on a external drives which I update after any major changes or every 3 months which ever comes first. Then these are kept in a safe place.
Yeah, sounds like you've got all the bases covered there 👍

Keeping a full clone on an external drive somewhere safe is a good idea. I've got Timeshift and my regular backups sorted now, but haven't gone as far as keeping a full clone.

Knowing me though, that'll probably end up being my next little project 😂
 
Yeah, sounds like you've got all the bases covered there 👍

Keeping a full clone on an external drive somewhere safe is a good idea. I've got Timeshift and my regular backups sorted now, but haven't gone as far as keeping a full clone.

Knowing me though, that'll probably end up being my next little project 😂
If its Important to you, the words are better safe than sorry 🙂 (y)
 
If its Important to you, the words are better safe than sorry 🙂 (y)
That’s convinced me. 👍 I’m going to get a 4TB drive at the beginning of next month and use it purely as an external backup for both my main PC and the Pi 5. I’d rather spend a few quid on another drive than find out the hard way that I should have done it. Better safe than sorry. 😄
 
Back
Top